5 New Haven Favorites to Elevate Your Holiday Table

Stumped on what to bring to your holiday celebration? We’ve got you covered with crowd-pleasing ideas that’ll make you the star of the table. Whether you’re looking for a savory dish, a pie for the table, or something in between, our city’s diverse collection of eateries, bakeries, and local markets offers a wealth of flavors. With everything from classic comfort foods to creative, modern twists on traditional recipes, we’re spotlighting five options for your dinner table.

The fresh egg nog from Arethusa Farm is the stuff of legends. Milk and cream blended with cage-free eggs, vanilla, and the finest spices from the West Indies, and you’ve got a holiday classic in a glass. Pro tips: serve it chilled over ice, gently headed, or mixed with a splash of your favorite holiday cheer..

Brunch is covered with fixings from Olmo Bagels, complete with schmear and lox. The best bagels in New Haven, Olmo’s are the perfect balance of crispy on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside – the way a bagel should be.

In the year of the “sweet treat,” dessert cannot disappoint. Pick up a pack of cupcakes, a macaroon of every color, and a slew of other baked goods from Sweet Mary’s on Court Street.

Italian Christmas traditions don’t mess around – they’re all about indulgence, flavor, and family feasts that go on for hours. Go to the source and pick up a traditional Panettone and fresh-made bread from G. Cafe Bakery. Their time-honored techniques deliver that melt-in-your-mouth texture and rich, citrusy flavor that only comes from years of tradition.

Look at that; your glass is empty. Stock up on fine wines, premium liquors, and specialty beers from The Wine Thief. Whether you’re stocking up for a cozy night in or the ultimate holiday party, The Wine Thief’s shelves are prepped and ready.